5 Great Thrift Stores Worth the Drive in Circleville, OH

1. Good Neighbor Thrift Store (Lancaster, OH)

Located right up the road in Lancaster, this church-run thrift store has lots of great options. If you’re looking for clothes, toys, dishes, or electronics, this is a great place to stop in and take a look around. Check out their Facebook or website for more information.

2. Now and Then Shop (Circleville, OH)

This is more of an antique thrift shop. You’ll find some beautiful vintage furniture at Now and Then Shop as well as dishes you may have seen in your grandma’s kitchen. Whether you’re hauling a suitcase full of clothes or an antique settee, our 2022 Ford F-350SD XL is the perfect vehicle for all your thrifting finds. With plenty of space in the bed of the pickup and a spacious crew cab, there will be room to take all your friends thrifting with you!

3. Pickaway Craft Mall (Pickaway County, OH)

New to our list and a standout for local shoppers, Pickaway Craft Mall is a blend of handmade crafts, antique finds, vintage goods, and repurposed furniture. It’s a great spot for anyone who loves a mix of old and new. Booths are stocked by local vendors, so the inventory is always changing—and you never know what you’ll come across!

4. Two Old Broads and a Geezer (Circleville, OH)

Make sure you give yourself ample time when you stop into this darling store; Two Old Broads and a Geezer. With just a little of everything, you will find some wonderful treasures here. New inventory is rotated in frequently, so you can go back repeatedly and will always find new bargains. From vintage dishes to home decor to furniture, you’ll be able to find what you are looking for, or not looking for, here. If you can’t find something, just ask the friendly owners to help! 

5. Goodwill – Morris Road (Circleville, OH)

While Goodwill stores are known nationwide, this location on Morris Road in Circleville often has an impressive variety of home goods, furniture, and clothing at budget-friendly prices. It’s a reliable stop for those seeking quality secondhand items and you may even find some high-end surprises tucked among the racks.

Whether you’re furnishing your first apartment or just love the thrill of the hunt, this Goodwill location is worth a visit.

After you’ve filled your vehicle with vintage finds and hidden gems, stop by Coughlin Ford of Circleville to upgrade your ride for future thrifting adventures. From spacious SUVs to trucks with serious hauling power, we’ve got a vehicle to fit every style—and every haul.

📍 Come see us in Circleville and let our team help you find your next set of wheels!

Image via Now and Then Shop.

Posted in Circleville, OH Community | No Comments »